Fine-tuning vs RAG

Fine-tuning changes a model's weights so that it behaves differently. RAG (retrieval-augmented generation) leaves the model alone and puts relevant documents into the prompt at query time. One teaches skills, the other supplies facts.

How they differ

Fine-tuningRAG
Changesthe model's weightsthe prompt
Good forformat, tone, task skill, domain languagefacts that are private, numerous or change often
New informationneeds a new training runupdate the index
Sourcesno document to point tothe answer can cite what was retrieved
Costtraining up frontretrieval and a longer prompt on every call

Which to pick

  • The model lacks knowledge (your documents, your product, this week's data). Use RAG. Weights are a poor place to store facts: the model recalls them unreliably and they go stale.
  • The model knows enough but answers the wrong way (format, style, steps, tool use). Fine-tune.
  • The prompt is long because of instructions and examples, not documents. Fine-tune, and the prompt shrinks.

Using both

The two combine. A common setup is a model fine-tuned to read retrieved passages, quote them, and say when the answer is not there, with RAG supplying the passages. The embedding model that does the retrieval can be fine-tuned too.

Retrieved text is untrusted input: see RAG security.

In Halo

sft tunes the model that writes the answer, and embedding tunes a model for retrieval. See training methods.

Train your own models

Post-train any Hugging Face model with Halo. Up to 4× faster than TRL